Bookish, Discussions

‘I’m Going To Read It Anyway & See What I Think’

As a blogger, I read book reviews almost daily. Whether it be here on WordPress, Tumblr, Instagram, or Goodreads, I use them as a guide to find out whether a book I’m thinking of reading is really worth it. Granted, you don’t have to use them, and I’ve often dived into a book without knowing what it’s about or what people have said about it (it’s one of my favourite things to do), but hey, reviews are useful!

As a book blogger, I also write them, and while I don’t write reviews of books that I just stopped reading after a short while for no particular reason, I do write reviews of books that I did not like and also include, if necessary, warnings about scenes or chapters that some may find triggering and/or upsetting. I want my reviews to, if positive, entice readers into picking up the book and sharing the joy that I felt. But I review the books that I did not enjoy to make aware to my readers and others who are browsing the reviews on goodreads of why I don’t think said book is worth your time.

However, at the end of the day, I cannot decide for you whether or not you read a book; my opinion may contribute to that decision, but reading tastes are reading tastes and my opinion will not be the same as yours. And that’s ok!

Whether or not a reviewer likes the book or not is very different to a reviewer stating the problematic issues in a book.

Vocal debates on this topic have been surfacing around once a month about these two definitions and how they’ve been overlapping. While the same issues happen with disabled bloggers, LGBT+ bloggers and Muslim bloggers, it’s specifically POC bloggers who are constantly being harassed online for their reviews of books that they have stated have racist content and therefore should be at least called out on to make others aware.

The problem does not lie in bloggers making readers aware of racist content, what is worrying are the many (white) people who respond to these criticisms with ‘I’m going to read it anyway and see what I think’.

In my scenario, where I give a book two stars because I didn’t enjoy it, that’s where a statement like that would be ok. Books are subjective, and ‘the writing style is poor’ is an opinion that another reader may not share. However, when POC review a book and say it’s racist, a white person cannot then decide to ‘see what they think’, because here are your two outcomes:

Outcome 1: You read the book and agree yes, it is racist. You have therefore ignored the claim of a person who actually experiences said racism in real life in favour of yours, as if there’s does not mean anything unless you’ve waved in on it.

Outcome 2: You read the book and disagree, it is not racist. You have therefore ignored the claim of a person who actually experiences said racism in real life in favour of yours, as if you can decide what does and does not clarify as racism.

I think the crux of the matter is people don’t like it when they are told not to read a book. Of course, when someone tells you not to do something, you kind of wanna do it, right? But here’s the thing, racism is not an opinion. That book, whether you read it or not, dislike it or not, has racist content. So, you cannot ‘read it and see what you think’. And when these bloggers/reviewers are asking you not to support these books, they are not trying to restrict your reading, they are trying to let publishers know that books like these cannot slide, that they are problematic and should not be getting published in the first place. Institutional racism is deep and ingrained and small justices can make large waves. Read the books if you want, but keep aware, and support the voices who are hurt by racist, homophobic, and ableist content.

You see a person stepping on another person’s foot without realising. They walk away. The person whose foot has been stepped on is hurt and rubbing their foot. They come up to you. “Did you see that? That really hurt.” Would you then question if that actually hurt them? Or would you have to find out for yourself and step on their foot too?

GoodreadsInstagram | Twitter | Tumblr



  1. Tanja

    April 30, 2017 at 5:53 pm

    Great post. If I read a review that says a book is racist, especially if they quote the racist parts of it, there’s no need for me to read the book and check for myself. But to be honest, if there’s some new book that sounds amazing to me and I really want to read it, I usually avoid the reviews because I don’t want to accidentaly come across a spoiler. So sometimes I miss the warnings that everyone else already knows about.

    1. hollie (hollieblog)

      April 30, 2017 at 5:56 pm

      Agreed! I think it just becomes a problem when readers want to read the book to ‘decide for themselves’. I read Nevernight without realising or noticing the problematic content and while I love it, I won’t ‘decide for myself’ whether it’s racist or not because it’s not an opinion.

  2. Kelly | Kelly's Rambles

    April 30, 2017 at 10:18 pm

    Hollie I agree with everything you have said here! This is a fantastic post!

    1. hollie (hollieblog)

      April 30, 2017 at 10:54 pm

      Thankyou so much Kelly!

  3. ruby2227

    May 1, 2017 at 6:23 pm

    1000% agree. Books are never perfect, sad to say, but some are objectively worse than others when it comes to good representation–and dismissing the opinions of people who genuinely know what they’re talking about is unbearably arrogant. The attitude needs to be shifted from “someone says I can’t do this so I’m gonna” to “someone says this is problematic, and if I do read it I’m going to take that into account.”

  4. Lauren @ Wonderless Reviews

    May 4, 2017 at 10:08 am

    Yesss! Great post, Hollie. Every time I see white people trying to say when a book is or isn’t racist I just sit there like “……what the hell?”. We have no right to decide that. “I’m going to read it anyway” should be reserved for books where people say the writing was poor or there was a love triangle. It’s like when people call out problematic issues in people’s faves. Like, stop ignoring it and start acknowledging it.

Leave a Reply